With a median 2025 sales price of $9.5M, Fisher Island has overtaken Atherton, CA, as the most expensive zip code in the US, per Property Shark’s just-released report. It’s Florida’s first time atop the list. Here, three listings in the neighborhood that came to market in the last month.
→ 5053 Fisher Island #5053 (Fisher Island) • 3BR/3.1BA, 3069 SF condo • Ask: $8.5M • renovated bayview with marble floors throughout • Days on market: 19 • Annual tax: $47,457 • Agents: Karla Abaunza & Jorge Escasena, Luxe Living.
→ 7966 Fisher Island Dr #7966 (Fisher Island, above) • 2BR/3BA, 2530 SF condo • Ask: $9.0M • oversized terraces and panoramic ocean views • Days on market: 33 • Annual tax: $50,593 • Agent: Evelyn Mackenzie, Aria Luxe.
→ 5134 Fisher Island Dr #5134 (Fisher Island) • 4BR/4.1BA, 4109 SF condo • Ask: $11.98M • bayside terraces and porcelain floors • Days on market: 9 • Annual tax: $64,704 • Agent: Jill Eber, Coldwell Banker.